Here is the current draft for my Women's Services blogpost for Monday. It's a topic that I'm pretty passionate about. If you have any suggestions or feedback on it, I'd love to hear it.
The adversary seems to work by counterfeits. He takes something good and true and finds a way to create a corrupted replica, which he tries to sell as the real thing. Usually these things limit us or burden us, where truth would otherwise set us free. A while back I started a counterfeit collection, a list of counterfeited concepts that, undetected, have been damaging. My list includes deceptive pairs such as confidence vs. pride, humility vs. self-deprecation, talking vs. communicating, love vs. lust, selflessness vs. no self, assertiveness vs. aggressiveness, faith vs. passive belief, repentance vs. behavior change, and reverence vs. just quietly sitting.

But of all of the counterfeits that I have been able to identify thus far, the one that I feel is potentially most detrimental to religious women is the counterfeiting of guilt into shame.
I believe that true guilt is something that is positive and functional that God has given us. But it is often misunderstood and counterfeited. As I see it, real guilt exists to tell us two things. First, it reminds us of the goodness of our spirits and our desires to do right. It is a reminder of our nobleness. We would not feel badly if we did not wish to do and be better. Secondly, guilt can be used as a reminder of our capacity to change and our desire to change, something made possible through the Atonement of Jesus Christ. If we can see guilt as an invitation to come unto Christ, knowing that He will forgive us and help us be better, then guilt can come to be seen as a merciful functional symptom of sin that helps direct us to the source of healing.
Unfortunately, guilt has many counterfeits. There is socially constructed and manipulative false guilt, which can be seen in the form of guilt trips which direct someone to feel responsibility for not meeting unhealthy obligations to another’s self-serving rules which can be based on other counterfeits. For example, perfectionism is a counterfeit attached to a rule dictating that we must be perfect or we are not good enough. If we believe that lie, then we feel false guilt every time we act imperfectly. This is a way that the adversary binds us and causes us to cast away our confidence in ourselves. Others’ criticisms often are based on their own belief that others should be more perfect, and thus they train people to feel false guilt. In these cases, it is helpful to become aware of underlying counterfeits and learn to break the unhealthy rules that surround them. Doing so breaks bonds that can bind us.

Another counterfeit of guilt is shame. Generally speaking, guilt is defined as feeling negatively about what they have done. Shame is feeling negatively about who they are. Guilt is feeling badly. Shame is feeling bad. Guilt is saying, “I feel badly that I hurt someone”. Shame is saying, “I feel bad because I am a mean person.” A guilty person recognizes the need to change his or her behavior in order to be more consistent with who he or she is inside. A shamed person lacks hope that they can change because they feel that who they are is so irreparably flawed. A guilty person can see pain as a function of healing, whereas a shamed person believes that pain and suffering is a punishment that they deserve.
The prophet Alma, who himself knew the pain of guilt and repentance, taught his son Corianton how to discern between these counterfeits of guilt and shame.
“And now, my son, I desire that ye should let these things trouble you no more, and only let your sins trouble you, with that trouble which shall bring you down unto repentance.” (Alma 42:29)
I interpret this to mean that our guilt and our pain are intended to invite us to repentance. To hold onto that pain, or to invite further pain, or to otherwise feel badly for the sake of feeling bad without it inviting us to Christ, does not come from Christ. It is a counterfeit of the adversary. The adversary wants us to hurt, to feel that we aren’t worthy of the Atonement and of happiness. He will try to trick us any way that he can. But Christ can set us free. His truth can set us free. Men are that they might have joy. The adversary’s lies can be captivating. They are patterned after truths and are easy to believe. But they invite us to give up hope. Shame tells us that we are unable to change. The truth is that God loves us and that change and improvement is always an option. That is why we are blessed with the ability to feel guilt and godly sorrow—as a reminder and invitation to change and become better.
In 2 Nephi 9:52 there is a line that reads “Let your hearts rejoice.” “Let” implies choice. If Satan has tricked you into thinking that you do not deserve to rejoice, don’t get caught in his lie. We needn’t be bound by his counterfeits if we can identify them and replace them with the truth. The truth is that you are amazing and you are loved, and that the Lord’s arms will always be outstretched to you, especially when you are imperfect.