Tuesday, December 6, 2016

My studies on Moroni

There are several of my former Athens Stake YCLs who are now serving as full-time missionaries.  I think about them often, I pray for them, and sometimes I write them letters.  But for some reason, I rarely send those letters.  I need to be better about that.  I recently rediscovered this letter that I wrote to one of them a few months ago but have not yet sent.  But I will soon!  In light of the #LightTheWorld initiative focusing on studying the scriptures today, I thought that my reporting on my scripture studies about Moroni in this letter was worth sharing.  So here it is.  Enjoy!

02 October 2016
Dear Sisters,

Oh, hey sister missionary!  I am smiling so big right just thinking of you serving the Lord as a full-time missionary!  You are so amazing!  I hope that you don’t mind my writing you.  I asked your mom for your address, and she was kind enough to oblige—and we exchanged a few facebook messages about how awesome you are!

Now, I’m a little out of letter-writing practice, so I apologize if this comes off as disorganized or preachy.  I used to write a lot of letters to missionaries when my sisters and cousins were serving several years back, and I followed a bit of a pattern:  I would greet them, provide a small update on happenings in my life, respond to any questions (if there was back-and-forth correspondence), and then I would share a story from the scriptures and apply it to life or missionary work.  I want to try bringing that pattern to play in this and any future letters I may send to you.

So the first paragraph was my greeting, so now for an update on me.  I am still living in Arizona, still in love with the Gospel and the scriptures, and I currently work full-time as a therapist as well as teach an online class on The Family Proclamation for BYU-Idaho.  I probably need to more actively work on being sociable, but life is good overall and I feel very blessed by my Heavenly Father.

Okay, let’s jump into the scriptures.  Oh how I love the scriptures, especially the Book of Mormon!  I want to share some insights from a recent study.  Last Sunday I gave a fireside to Single Adults on the topic The Family: A Proclamation to the World and the Non-traditional Family.  Since my audience was composed of people who were single, divorced or widowed/widowered, I wanted to focus on the significance of the Proclamation to those whose lives don’t reflect the ideal family situation.  And I wanted to invite them to still hold up the Proclamation like the Title of Liberty and be an advocate for it and the doctrines, principles and standards it contains.  I spent a few weeks studying various family types in the scriptures and ended up deciding to use Moroni, son of Mormon as an example of a powerful Single Adult who understood the divine importance of the family and who was instrumental in advocating for eternal families in some pretty special ways.

So…some interesting information from the scriptures about Moroni.  (P.S. Sorry if this isn’t the most relevant topic for your stage of life, but perhaps it can be of value to many of those who you teach as a missionary.) 

Now, I suppose I can’t say it definitively, but it is my interpretation that Moroni spent much of his life as a single man.  He told us in Mormon 8 that “I even remain alone…for I am alone.  My father hath been slain in battle, and all my kinsfolk, and I have not friends nor whither to go…”  We don’t know if being left alone makes him a widower, or if he was a bachelor, but he was single and he knows loneliness.

Sometimes, when I get lonely, I like to study Moroni.  It is reasonable to assume that he was left alone, wandering with the plates for several decades.  In Moroni 1 he noted that the Lamanites “put to death every Nephite that will not deny the Christ.  And I, Moroni, will not deny the Christ; wherefore, I wander whithersoever I can for the safety of mine own life.”  He wandered alone for a long time, and largely felt directioness: “whither I go it mattereth not”. 

I think that a lot of people, especially singles in the church, can relate to this experience of feeling alone, lonely, and unsure of where to go or what to do.  Moroni had hope and a sense of eternal purpose, but the day to day was probably much more difficult.

So, what did Moroni do when he felt alone?  When his dad had been killed in battle?  When he had no friends or relatives to turn to?  We don’t know entirely.  But, we can discern a few things than he may have done, and that it would seem that he didn’t do.

We first know that Moroni didn’t give up.  In Moroni 9:6 we read advice Moroni received from his dad in a letter: “And now, my son, notwithstanding their hardnesss, let us labor diligently; for if we should cease to labor, we should be brought under condemnation; for we have a labor to perform whilst in this tabernacle of clay, that we may conquer the enemy of all righteousness, and rest our souls in the kingdom of God.”

From that verse we can also surmise that he labored diligently, and that he held on to hope that someday he would be able to rest his soul in the kingdom of God with his family.  That verse, which is part of a letter Mormon wrote to Moroni, also makes me think that Moroni probably often turned to both the scriptures and the letters from his dad that he held on to over all those years.   It probably brought him a lot of comfort to see the 17 times he was referred to as “son” and to remember that he was part of an eternal family.  I think that reading a sermon from his dad (contained now in Moroni 7) helped influence the development of his character and faith.

Moroni 7 is the powerful sermon on faith, hope and charity.  I believe that Moroni epitomized all three of those attributes in ways that few others on earth have because of the circumstances he was in and how he chose to respond in those circumstances.

Consider this as it relates to charity.  When Moroni first writes in the Book of Mormon, it is in Mormon 8.  In reading that chapter, there are some subtle indications that Moroni viewed the Lamanites in a “them” versus “us” way (see verses 3 and 7).  Which makes sense seeing as how he was a leader in the military fighting them, and how they were responsible for the death of his family, friends and people.  However, by the time he writes in Ether 12, something has changed in his heart.  In verse 38 he refers to them as “my brethren whom I love”.  This comes only a few verses after he wrote about faith, hope and charity himself.  And in verse 34 he acknowledges before the Lord, “except men shall have charity they cannot inherit that place which though hast prepared in the mansions of thy Father”.  He then references the consequences for not having charity.

We again see evidence of Moroni’s charity in Moroni 1 when he again refers to the posterity of the Lamanites as “my brethren”, and states that his purpose for having created additional plates and writing on them is solely for their benefit.  He hasn’t forgotten what the Lamanites did.  Two verse before stating his purpose and view of them as brethren, he stated that “because of their hatred they put to death every Nephite…”  But he loves them anyway.

Moroni remains humble enough to love.  This has to be hard.  Understanding what I do about human nature and defense mechanisms, it must have been so tempting for him to try to numb out, to harden his heart, to hate or to blame.  And perhaps he did for a while, I don’t know.  But ultimately, he was able to love those who persecuted him, and do good to those who would have killed him if they could.

Moroni is such a stud!  Wow…this is turning out really long.  I’m going to skip most of the other things I could write about Moroni the powerhouse single adult and just mention one or two more things that I think are super significant.  And these relate to making the blessings of eternal families available to everyone.

In D&C section 2, we are able to read the worlds of Moroni to Joseph Smith.  Consider that Moroni was selected to be instrumental in ushering in the restoration!  One of the things he taught Joseph, and that is the first section recorded after “The Lord’s Preface” in section 1, is about promises related to the family, the Priesthood and the sealing power: “Behold, I will reveal unto you the Priesthood, by the hand of Elijah the prophet, before the coming of the great and dreadful day of the Lord.  And he shall plant in the hearts of the children the promises made to the fathers, and the hearts of the children shall turn to their fathers.  If it were not so, the whole earth would be utterly wasted at his coming.”  

Elijah held the keys to the sealing power.  In understanding the purpose of the earth in Heavenly Father’s plan, we know that it is a place prepared for us to be born into families, and make and keep covenants that bring us back to the presence of God in families.  That chapter/section is about the importance of eternal families made possible through Priesthood ordinances in holy temples.

And Moroni’s image tops almost all of the Lord’s temples built in this dispensation.  I think that it is really cool that Moroni was able to be an advocate for the family even though he spent most of mortality without his own.  I think that it is significant that the Lord trusted him with responsibilities and power.  And I consider him to be a great example of being faithful in lonely and perilous circumstances.  I am so grateful for his example, for his writings, and for the role he played in the compiling of the scriptures and the ushering in of the restoration.  

If you read this entire letter, bravo.  I promise to make the next one at least a little bit shorter.  I guess I have a hard time containing my excitement when thinking and writing about the scriptures.  Like Nephi, "my soul delighteth in the scriptures" (2 Nephi 4:15).  They are amazing and they are true!

I am so proud of who you are and the decisions that you are making!  I anticipate that as you serve you will experience a roller coast of emotions as you love and have your heart broken by those you serve and teach.  I hope that you will turn to the Savior in both your joy and sorrow so that he can consecrate those experiences for your sake.

Know that you are missed, thought of, prayed for, admired and loved.  You are a very special person with so much love and light to give to others.  I am grateful for your example to me and for the love and optimism and faith that you have shared.

Oh, and if you do have any interest in corresponding, I’d love to keep in touch.  I’d love to hear about the tender mercies you experience, the trials you face that have the potential to refine you, stories about the people you serve and serve with, insights from your studies, and/or the fun and funny experiences that you have if you ever feel like sharing.  But I know your time is limited, so don’t feel as though you need to.  Just know that I am interested and I care.  Also, know that you are loved.


Onward, ever onward,

Sister Allison Ellsworth

Thursday, November 10, 2016

My Reaction to Election Reactions

Disclaimer: I wrote this late at night and it might not be especially coherent.  You've been warned. :)

As I have observed reactions to the outcome of the recent Presidential election, I have noticed a trend that is somewhat unsettling to me.   I am noticing a tendency to “other” people based on a singular difference, and I am noticing people caricaturize others based on their worst features.

This isn’t some new phenomenon.  Throughout the election it has been one of the major concerns and fears I have held regarding our now-President-elect.  The media has shone a spotlight on various comments in which Mr. Trump associates individuals of Mexican origin with druggies and rapists, associates refugees with terrorists, objectifies women, and suggests that various groups of people (often from vulnerable populations) should be feared or viewed with contempt. 

I am a believer that people are people, not the personification of their problems.  And certainly not the personifications of an exaggerated, atypical, stereotyped problem that is unjustly assigned to them.  Accordingly I do not approve of such dangerous overgeneralizations. 

I continue to hold concerns that Mr. Trump may make decisions that are not informed by an understanding of who individuals are, but rather by fears based on a few individuals’ worst qualities or actions.  I fear that he will think only of those few, unrepresentative outliers, and then overgeneralize their threat to a group of innocent individuals just because they share a racial, cultural or identity-based commonality.  I also have hope that these fears won’t be realized.  I hope that Mr. Trump’s potential as a leaders is not defined by some of the worst things that he has said and done.

But again, I am not writing this post to react to the election results or a particular candidate.  I am reacting to election reactions.  I am noticing that the response of many to Mr. Trump’s victory has been to other and negatively caricaturize him, the Republican Party, and any individuals who cast a vote for Mr. Trump, or who failed to cast a vote for Secretary Clinton.

I have read various facebook posts and comments that suggest that anyone who voted for Donald Trump is evil, hateful, bigoted, ignorant, and has a disregard for others.  I have seen comparisons of Donald Trump to Hitler.  I have seen individuals petition facebook friends who cast their ballots for Mr. Trump to unfriend them.  And I have seen a great deal of labeling: defining a person’s universal personhood with minimizing negative labels.  And seeing this makes me a little sad.

I recall an experience from a few years ago in which someone with whom I am associated made me aware of their disapproval of me and who felt inclined to unload seven years’ worth of criticisms on me.  I remember at one point interrupting and responding, “Yes, I have said some of those things and shouldn’t have, but you need to realize that that isn’t who I am”.  To which the response was, “No, that is exactly who you are.”  I remember how painful it was to be defined in someone else’s eyes based on a few past thoughtless and insensitive comments that are inconsistent with my character.  I remember driving home in tears and thinking about how out of all the things that define who I am and make up my character, that this individual had seemingly trained themselves to look for and remember the few things that re-enforced the negative story about me that they decided on after I had made a flippant comment years before.

Now, I know full well that my lifetime of cumulative offensive and insensitive comments is probably lesser that the offensive or insensitive things that Donald Trump says on a typical day.  And I have no interest in defending the indefensible or excusing the inexcusable.  But I still think that there is a principle in my story that is relevant.  Because this post isn’t meant to be about Trump.  It is meant to be about the natural tendency to other others, to define othered others by their worst parts, and to turn them into shallow caricatures rather than rich, complex, glorious individuals who can be understood and connected to. 

People are not two-dimensional cartoons.  Not all Republicans are the same.  Not all Democrats are the same.  Not all supporters of a given candidate are the same.  Not all people who voted for a particular candidate did so for the same reason.  Not all members of a particular ethnic or racial group are the same.  Not all women are the same.  Not all men are the same.  There is diversity within every demographic whether it be racial, religious, political or social.  And that diversity is beautiful.  And the stories each person carries are worth hearing.  But the beauty remains unseen and the stories remain unheard when individuals are grouped together, judged and deemed deplorable.  And from my vantage point, this othering and judgement and fear-mongering has occurred among some individuals from all major parties.

I do want to acknowledge that people's reactions makes sense.  When people try to make sense of things that don’t seem to make sense, it is natural for the mind to create categories and simplify things.  It is easy to look for someone or something to blame.  It is easy to want to try to make things black and white.  And a lot of people are reacting to genuinely felt fear and pain.  They are acting in defense of others they know who feel fear and pain.  I don’t wish to fault anyone for reacting to their feelings and experience.

Still, I believe that ultimately it will be easier to understand and build bridges as people are able to truly see one another.  To understand one another.  To hear a person’s story rather than see a single unflattering moment.  To find out why a person acted the way they did rather than jump to worst case assumptions.  Perpetuating the problem of characterizing people based on an action or characteristic that we disagree with and then using it to justify judgement, meanness and rejection does not serve the world.

I hope and pray that President Trump will seek to see and hear and understand those that he fears and those that he does not understand or agree with.  And I similarly hope that we all can similarly seek to understand and find points of connection and commonality, rather than define others by the way they are different than us.  To look at one action (such as a vote) or one belief (such as a position on a social issue) of any person and then feel justified in cutting that person out of our lives, or judging them as unworthy or corrupted is a tragedy in my eyes.  People and problems are complex.  People are in need of and worthy of understanding, love and connection.  In this time of political divisiveness and fear, I hope that we can see each other more fully, and turn to one another rather than against each other.

Friday, October 14, 2016

Election Thoughts: Trying to Articulate the Struggle

The election is less than a month away.  And I, like many others, have found myself dissatisfied with and resistant to considering either of the major parties’ nominees for president.  I perceive both as having said and done various things that cause me to neither respect them nor trust them to be in a position of power, leadership or influence over this country.  I went through a lengthy stage in which I told myself that I could not in good conscience cast a vote for either of them, and have been seriously considering third party or write-in alternatives.  For a while I was determined to support a third-party candidate.  But my conscience remained unsatisfied.  Voting for a third-party candidate does not soothe my conscience because I associate voting for a third-party candidate with surrendering greater influence by not voting for and/or against one of the two candidates who is most likely to end up appointed to the highest office in the land.  I fear that I will be abdicating my power to make a difference.  And I want to make a difference.

I have not yet determined for whom I am going to vote.  But I have narrowed it down to two.   And that short list includes one of the candidates that I previously told myself that I would not and could not vote for in good conscience.  Below I hope to explain why I am now possibly open to voting for a candidate I do not support despite my dislike of that candidate’s character and fear of damage that could be incurred under this person’s leadership.

The issues that matter most to me politically are social issues.  I care about society.  I love social science.  I am particularly interested in the moral development of individuals and of society.  This investment in society’s social and moral development repels me from both major parties’ candidates as individuals, but it also draws me toward the party and platform that best represents and supports the issues I most value. 

When I think of the potential of the next president to realistically appoint up to five Supreme Court Justices, it feels socially negligent to not advocate for someone who would likely appoint individuals who would justly advocate for the issues that I deem to be of the greatest value to the well-being of the nation.

I feel as though I am stuck in a moral dilemma.  Do I vote against individuals I don’t like, trust or have confidence in with a conscience-soothing third party vote but in doing so not have a say in who will realistically have influence?  Do I vote for a party and platform my values and interests more fully align with, knowing that my vote could contribute to a raise to power of someone that would easily abuse that power and do damage to the nation, its people and its foreign policy and relations? I feel stuck in a lose-lose situation.  I don’t know whether to prioritize supporting the party that I perceive as offering the most potential benefit or withholding support from the candidate that I anticipate would bring about the most immediate collateral damage.

In seeing how I wrote that last paragraph, I recognize that I am seeing a third-party candidate vote as being more about appeasing my conscience by not voting for people I don’t believe in rather than it being about voting for someone I do believe in.  Which is interesting.  Because I have found things I align with and admire in third party candidates.  And I have read and considered arguments for possible (but improbable) pathways to presidency or other gains from voting third-party and I find value and merit in those ideas.  But I also know that if I personally voted third party, it wouldn’t be with any expectation of that candidate winning, even if I want them to.

What’s more, I also wonder if I’m putting too much pressure on myself and on my individual vote.  Does my single vote really make a difference or have power and/or influence?  Honestly, probably not.  But I decided to ask myself, if I knew that my vote would be a tie-breaking vote, for whom would I vote?  And my honest answer to myself was: it depends.  If I knew that my vote would be a tie-breaker nationally and allow a preferred third-party candidate to win, I would vote for that person.  If I knew that my vote would be a tie-breaker at only the state level and most likely draw electoral votes away from the party I identify with, leaving the overall outcome of the election more likely to fall to the candidate of the opposing platform, then I would vote for the party’s candidate (despite the repugnance of that candidate).  

I also wonder, is my catastrophizing (assuming that either major candidate winning equates to abuse of power and irreparable damage) realistic and founded, or am I simply being overly influenced by a fear-mongering media?  Because I legitimately feel fearful of a presidency led by either major party candidate.  And I don't want to feel accountable for it or know that I supported it.  Is the damage that I can envision a likely outcome?  And is the threat of such outcomes sufficiently dangerous that I should not risk such an appointment despite the value of their alleged loyalty to promoting a specific platform?

I want to stand up for something.  I want to vote for what I believe.  But I also don’t want to vote for someone that I don’t believe in or that I want to stand up against.  How do I reconcile those?  Will a vote for someone who is likely to defend those things (despite potentially being despicable in other ways) be a way to cast my vote and voice for something that matters?  And is it worth the perceived risk?  Can a vote for a third party have influence in the areas that matter most to me?  These questions and others will be in my thoughts and prayers in the coming weeks as I seek to act consistent with the personal integrity, respect for this nation’s political processes, and a sense of responsibility to future generations that I feel should characterize my actions as I seek to fulfill my civic duty.

Friday, January 29, 2016

Hard Decisions and Defining Plan A


Today I received an email that reminded me of an email exchange I had back in November with an old friend.  She had asked me about my decision to leave my PhD program and today she followed up with me on her decision.  Also, yesterday another old friend reached out and made reference to my decision to leave my PhD program in a kind voicemail.

I remember hearing once that, oftentimes, repetition isn't redundancy, but revelation.  To have two friends from BYU days reach out within two days and make mention of the same event makes it seem like more than a coincidence to me.  Perhaps there is something I need to remember or reflect on.  And/or share.  Accordingly, I plan on doing some reflecting.  But for the sake of this blog post, I'm just going to share my email exchange, lest it be meaningful or interesting to anyone else.  Enjoy.

The initial email I received:

Hey, Allison,
I hope this finds you well. I'm emailing because I find myself in somewhat of an existential crisis and I thought you might have some advice. I'm in the first semester of my doc program. It's great so far. I enjoy my classes and research. But, I'm also expecting a baby... I'm trying to reconcile my plan A with my plan B and am considering not finishing my degree. I haven't decided anything yet, but am gathering information. I wanted to ask you what your reasons were for dropping out of your doc program. Are you happy with your decision? Would you make the same choice again, given the chance? Do you have any regrets? What have been the advantages and the disadvantages?
Thanks for your insight. I think you're pretty awesome. :-)

My Response:

Hey friend!

I was just thinking about you...and how I never responded to your text from forever ago.  Sorry!  I'm happy to hear from you.  Congratulations about expecting!

As one that has been through my version of that existential crisis, I am happy to share my experiences and process with you.  I'll tackle your questions one by one and then add a few extra thoughts at the end.

1. What were my reasons for dropping out of my doctoral program?
I had a few reasons for dropping out of my doctoral program.  The one I generally tell people (and myself) is that I decided that continuing in a doctoral program wasn't aligned with my professional goals.  I learned in the course of my program that I wasn't passionate enough about research.  I realized that I didn't want to end up in academia, but rather wanted to be a therapist who did some adjunct teaching on the side.  I know that both of those things were possible with the Masters degree I already had.  In my mind, it didn't make sense to incur more debt and invest more time to achieve a degree that I didn't really need.  My other reasons related to a self-perceived lack of proficiency in statistics and in what I like to call "inertia problems", ie, I had some mild depression that made it very difficult for me to motivate myself to do the work I needed and to do at a caliber that I was satisfied with... 

2. Am I happy with my decision?
I am at peace with my decision.  For me, it was a considerable process to make the decision that I did.  I did not want to quit.  I felt a sense of duty to complete what I started and didn't want to be casual about it.  I spent a long time pondering, praying, counseling with family and attending the temple before feeling that I'd received revelation to know how to proceed.  Because I felt assured that it was the right decision at that time for me, I have always felt at peace.

3. Would I make the same choice again, given the chance?
Yes.  However, if not for the assurance I found through personal revelation, I would likely feel differently.

4. Do I have any regrets?
No, not really.  There have been a few moments here and there where I wonder what it would have been like, or I feel slightly envious of friends who completed their doctorates.  And because I'm currently in a rather lame job, I sometimes wonder if it might have been better to stay for the free supervision.  But I feel good that my decision was the right decision for me to make.

5. What have been the advantages and the disadvantages?
The advantages have included avoiding further debt (I actually paid off all my student loans this year!), and moving into my desired profession a few years earlier than I would have otherwise.  Because I decided to move back to my hometown, I have also enjoyed being closer to family and being around nieces and nephews.  I can also make jokes about having dropped out of school. :)  Disadvantages are the feeling of being left behind and/or having wasted time.  On the one hand I feel like I wasted time professionally by spending two years in the program and not having anything to show for it when I otherwise could be licensed by now.  And, on the other hand, I see my classmates who do now have PhDs and think that it could have been me.  I have fewer skills than I likely would have if I had stayed in my program.  And I do miss having access to academic journals and attending and presenting at conferences.

You mentioned Plan A vs. Plan B.  Something that I learned a while back is that what I had labeled as my Plan A (marriage and family) and Plan B (profession in teaching and counseling) were mislabeled.  Now when I think of Plan A, I think of it as Heavenly Father's plan for me.  I would rather live by His plan and His timing than have things work out the way that I think I want.  So I just try to do my best to align my will to His, act in faith and do the best I can and trust that things will work out.

I am very grateful for my time in Georgia.  I learned a lot and grew a lot.  But I also feel confident that it was right for me to leave earlier than I anticipated.  I trust that I could have finished, but I don't think it would have helped me progress towards my immediate professional or personal goals.  That was the right decision for me.

My advice?  Figure out what Heavenly Father's plan is for you and allow that to inform your choices.  I strongly believe that there is no calling or role more influential and powerful than that of motherhood.  But I also know that the Lord often uses women as healers, teachers, leaders and in other roles.  I don't know His plan for you except that I trust that your contributions to the world, whether in your home or outside it, will make the world a better place.

Good luck in your decision-making.  I trust your ability to study things out by study and by faith and to make good choices.

I'd love to hear more about how things are going for you and your growing family!

Your friend,

Allison Ellsworth