Sunday, August 24, 2014

My Niece is Pretty Cute



Ruby's baby blessing was earlier this evening.  She's a good one.  I anticipate greatness.

Wednesday, August 20, 2014

My Response to the Cosmo article "I'm Fighting BYU's Ban on Sex"

The September issue of Cosmopolitan magazine will feature an article titled, “I’m Fighting BYU’s Ban on Sex”, an article that already appears online on their website.  The article is authored by a BYU student, who states that she wants “to start a discussion about changing an honor code that hurts women”. 

I am a big fan of having discussions about important social issues, especially women’s issues.  So I want to open up some discussion on this blog.  However, I’ll be upfront about my position: I do not consider the honor code to be a weapon against women.  I agreed with the author on a few points, but much of my contribution to the discussion will be to present dissenting perspectives.  I also hope that you readers will join in the discussion by sharing your perspectives and experiences in the comment section. 

To begin, I want to highlight a few issues that the article brings up that I agree with and feel are important and deserving of attention.  I want to make both of these points the subject of their own individual blog posts in the near future, and for that reason I won’t spend time addressing them today.  But I do want to acknowledge them:
-The use of shaming analogies (i.e. chewed gum) is an unhealthy and harmful method of sexuality education that needs to be abandoned
-A victim of sexual assault is NOT at fault for what happened and is not deserving of blame, judgment, or punishment

Okay, now I’m going to address some points that were made in the article in which the author and I had differing perspectives.

Why Are We Asked to Save Sex for Marriage?
The author of the article started by sharing a teaching that I anticipate is familiar to all Latter-day Saints: “I was told to save sex for marriage”.  Then, in the next sentence she referenced an analogy her teachers used in teaching this concept: The dreaded chewing gum analogy.  For those of you who are unfamiliar (and I really hope that is most of you), it likens someone who has broken the law of chastity to chewed gum.  In insinuates that such a person is no longer desirable and that they can’t return to the state they were in previously.  Gah.   Please.  Never use that analogy. 

The way the first paragraph of the article is written makes me wonder if that BYU student assumes that abstinence is just about remaining socially desirable (not turning into chewed gum or having to wear a scarlet letter).  If your rationale to wait until marriage for sex is so that you are a fresh piece of gum rather than a gross chewed one, then that is a problem.  It communicates a big misunderstanding of the “why” of the commandment that we remain chaste, and it shows that compliance to the commandment is motivated by fear rather than by a desire to act in accordance with truth.  That can lead to all sorts of misconceptions, to a fear of sexuality, and to shame even when sex happens within the marriage relationships.  Clearly, this is problematic.

So let’s review a few truths about sex.  

#1. Sex is good.  President Kimball taught that, in the right context, “The intimacy of sexual relations is right and divinely approved.” God created our bodies to be able to have and enjoy sex.    

#2. Sex is sacred.  Sex holds the potential for creation of life.  That is a divine power.  It also holds the potential to help two to become one and to be intimately united as husband and wife.  It is a context that allows genuine vulnerability and thus opportunities for real intimacy and connection.

#3. Sex is intended to be used within the context of marriage.  Prophets and apostles have declared, “…The sacred powers of procreation are to be employed only between man and woman, lawfully wedded as husband and wife”.

So, yes, sex is to be reserved for marriage.  BUT…we aren’t supposed to be abstinent before marriage to avoid being seen negatively.  We aren’t supposed to be abstinent before marriage in order to avoid STIs.  And we aren’t abstinent before marriage to avoid getting pregnant out of wedlock.  We ARE asked and commanded by a loving Father to be chaste before marriage because sex is wonderful and holy and is created to be used within a marital relationship for divine purposes. 

So, keep that in mind.  And as you think back to the title of the Cosmo article, “I’m Fighting BYU’s Ban on Sex”, realize that it isn’t BYU’s ban.  Think of 1 Nephi 3:5.
“…Thy brothers murmur, saying it is a hard thing which I have required of them; but behold I have not required it of them, but it is a commandment of the Lord”.
Abstinence before marriage and fidelity within marriage is the Lord’s standard for all His children, regardless of their gender or the school they attend.  It isn’t an institution trying to the restrict freedom of women, it is a commandment of God instituted to allow the greatest freedom and happiness for both His sons and daughters.

Let’s look at a few more things in the article.

Is BYU Slut-Shaming?
The author mentions her involvement with a group that talked about “how the Church doesn’t see women as equal to men and how BYU is slut-shaming”.   For the sake of time, I am going to forgo addressing the equality issue today, but will address the slut-shaming accusation.  But first, a disclaimer:

I am not sure if the article's references to “BYU” and “the Church” is in reference to majority perspectives, the perspectives of administrators, or simply some individuals she has encountered.  And I am not in a position to speak for either school or church leadership or the majority of individuals in either body.  But I do wish to raise my own voice in defense of what I believe and what I have experienced when I was a BYU student and presently as a faithful member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

I have never experienced “BYU”--either its policies or the majority of its students--as being “slut-shaming”.  I myself, as a BYU alumni, do not believe in shaming anyone.  Shaming others is inconsistent with the gospel of Jesus Christ.  Christ’s interaction with the woman taken in adultery was compassionate and private.   I would hope that all BYU students, faculty, administrators and staff would seek to follow that example.  And, in my optimism, I assume that most do.

Further, I do not believe in using the word “slut” as it is disrespectful to women and is inherently shaming.  I do not recall ever hearing the word used during my seven years at BYU, and hope the word and the attitude associated with it are not common to campus. 

If I were to be aware that an individual’s choices and actions were inconsistent with the honor code and the law of chastity (which is what I assume the author is referencing when using the term “slut”), I would recognize that it would not be my place to judge.

I agree that the honor code does not embrace, promote or condone living contrary to the law of chastity, but that does not constitute “slut-shaming”.

Does the Honor Code Force Us to Wear Knee-Length Clothing?
The article then makes mention of the dress and grooming standards in the honor code, indicating that the honor code “forces” women to wear clothes to the knee, “supposedly to help men control their thoughts”.  I reviewed the honor code to understand where this interpretation may have come from.  But what I found was inconsistent with the author's conclusions.  The “why” of the dress standards are more individual that relational (i.e. for the sake of the individual rather than for the sake of someone else’s thoughts).  The honor code reads, “Modesty and cleanliness are important values that reflect personal dignity and integrity, through which students, staff, and faculty represent the principles and standards of the Church.”  There is NO clause that says, “…and so that male students will more easily avoid lustful thoughts”.  It’s not there.  Trust me.  I checked.

Of course feeling coerced would naturally lead to resistance.  However, we are not “forced” to dress a certain way.  Students at BYU voluntarily agree to abide by honor code standards.  And of course it would be upsetting to feel that standards set for women were for the benefit of men.  But these standards are not for the benefit of others.  They are a reflection of individual dignity and integrity.            

Are Non-Virgins Treated as Inferiors?
I want to address just one more statement found in the Cosmo article.  The author wrote, “Women at BYU who aren’t virgins are treated as inferiors and that’s not fair”. 

I’m going to be painfully honest here. I wouldn’t be surprised if there were many who would see and treat women who they knew were not virgins differently.  But I doubt it is for the reason that that author believes.  At least I hope it isn’t.

Here’s where I’m coming from.  As a BYU student, I had a few roommates who I knew were not keeping the law of chastity, and by extension the honor code.  And it did impact how I saw them.  But it was never about “virginity”.  My judgmental-ness wasn’t about sex.  It was about what commitments and covenants and sacred things meant to them.  Because they mean everything to me. 

When I had roommates who didn’t live consistent with the honor code and the law of chastity, I distanced myself from them.  I wanted my closest friends to be people who valued gospel standards as much as I did.  I didn’t shame them or treat them as of less worth.  But I did see and treat them differently.  I didn’t invest as much in those relationships.  And I made some assumptions about them.  I didn’t consider them to be as trustworthy because I observed their lack of commitment to Honor Code, which is something that I loved and took seriously.  I didn’t respect them as much because of their choices and actions.  Did I think of them as inferior?  Maybe on some level I did think that they were morally inferior.  And that was wrong of me.

Would You Date Someone Who Wasn’t a Virgin?
I want to look at this idea of seeing non-virgins as inferior in the context of serious dating relationships now.  And rather than considering all non-virgins, I want to refer particularly to those who have broken the law of chastity after having first had a knowledge of that law.  

And, of course, as a female, I don’t know how guys feel about girls who are not virgins.  But I’ll be honest about how I’d feel about being in a relationship with a guy who had previously transgressed the law of chastity. 

If I were to learn that a guy that I was seriously dating had not lived the law of chastity previously, then that would be a big yellow flag for me.  And when I was an undergraduate student, it probably would have been a big, flashing red flag. 

If I were to learn that at this point in my personal development (I like to think that I’m a little bit more mature at 30 than I was at 20) that someone that I was dating seriously had previously engaged in sexual acts with someone else outside of marriage, with a knowledge that it was contrary to God’s laws, I would want to have a hard conversation with them.  Because I would wonder about his commitment to his covenants.  And I would want to know his attitudes toward chastity.  I would question if he would be trustworthy to keep the law of chastity within our relationship.  I would question his level of commitment to keeping the commandments.  We’d need to have that discussion because those things matter to me.  A lot. 

However, as I mentioned, it would be a yellow light situation.  It wouldn’t necessarily be a deal-breaker.  If he could engage in that discussion and I could see that we shared a love of God, a commitment to each other and the relationship, and a valuing of covenants, then I would proceed in the relationship.  I do believe that people are not defined by what they have done in the past. 

BUT when I was a young, idealistic, somewhat ignorant and insensitive undergraduate, it might have been different.  Upon learning of a history of breaking the law of chastity, I would likely have made assumptions about him, judged him, and instead of maturely talking about it, I would have been too nervous, insecure or awkward to discuss it.  And I would have likely just ended things. 

And, in all reality, that isn’t fair.  My ignorance and fear would have caused me to act immaturely and insensitively.  And it would not have been fair to who that person may have become.   It wouldn’t have shown the respect merited to someone who exercised the courage to disclose that information.  And it may have sent the message that I thought that he was unclean or inferior.  And that would be wrong of me.  Chances are, I wasn't the only BYU undergrad with the potential to judge others unfairly.  Hopefully I’m not the last to learn to see people as people and not as their past mistakes.

Conclusion
There is a lot more that I could have written, but this is already a ridiculously long blog post.  So I’m going to wrap up.

I do not doubt that there are individuals on campus who are overtly disrespectful and shaming.  And I am confident that others are innocently ignorant and end up inflicting a great deal of hurt.  There is a need for discussion on several issues in order to invite more people to remember both the humanity and the divinity of all people, regardless of the choices they make.  But still, even with all the weakness in the thousands of BYU co-eds walking around campus, I do not believe that BYU, the Church, or the Honor Code is as shaming and oppressive as that article has made it out to be.

I love BYU.  It provided me a wonderful education, incredible friends, and it deepened my discipleship.  The Church has helped me to know the Savior, learn the Gospel, and have access to covenants that protect me, give me strength, and provide me perspective in life.  And I also love the Honor Code.  I chose to continuing follow those same standards while attending a graduate program in Georgia, and I continue to adopt those guidelines now because they help me to keep sacred my covenants.

I hope that those of you who read the Cosmo article found its claims as surprising and shortsighted as I did.  But I can’t help but believe that to its author, these were real concerns based on experiences she has had.  Which means that somewhere there is a need for change.  I don’t think that place is the Honor Code, and I certainly don’t think that the law of chastity needs to be changed.  I do, however, believe that there are people who need to change.  And the way I see it, the kind of change that is needed will grow out of a correct understanding of the principles and doctrines of the Gospel.


*I read this blogpost which indicated that the BYU student attributed to writing the original article didn't write the article, but rather it was based on a phone interview with her.  Apparently several things she said were taken out of context and don't fully represent her perspectives.  Accordingly, I removed her name from my post in an attempt to not misrepresent her further.  Still, my content remains the same since it is written in reaction to what potentially millions of people are reading in the Cosmopolitan article.

Friday, August 8, 2014

New Blog

So...I started a new blog.  It's sort of a professional development project.  I feel like I'm planting seeds in hopes that in a few years it can be a good referral source and brand legitimizer for me.  With this new blog I'm trying to be somewhat  professional in my subject matter (the most recent post is on antidepressant treatment options), but I'm also trying to have an authentic voice and be true to me (hence the parable about gopher holes and a post about How to Train Your Dragon).  The blog is called Waxing Strong, which was inspired, in part, by Helaman 3:35.  And in my first post I explain what waxing strong means to me and how it relates to my goals for the blog and my work as a therapist.

Moral of the story: I'd love to have you check it out and give me some feedback if anything stands out to you.  What do you think of the design?  Does my writing flow well?  Do you have any recommendations on topics?  Was a too casual or too formal?  I'm open to feedback if you want to share it and have time to.  Oh, and if you like my blog, I would love to have you follow it and comment on posts or share posts you think are worth sharing if ever you feel so inclined.  Hopefully someday in the future (I'm thinking by the time I want to go into private practice in 3-5 years) that this blog will be something that will show up when people google search for therapists in the area, and it will have content that causes them to have confidence in me.

I'll occasionally still write on this blog too.  I won't get religious on the new blog, and there will be times that I will want to share my scripture and gospel insights.  I'll probably write some of those thoughts here.  And there will be times where I will want to share good news with family and friends.  Oh, by the way...I received my associate license in the mail on Friday!  I've been taking advantage of an semi-justifiable opportunity to put "LAMFT" after my name.  It's been fun.  Also, I've been offered a position teaching an online course with BYU-I next semester.  I still need to fill out some paperwork, but I'm pretty sure that is going to happen.  I'm excited!  Yay part-time job!  So...there's my good news.  On this blog.  So there you go.

Well, here is the new website: http://waxingstrong.wordpress.com/.  I'll probably update it once or twice a week.  Either Mondays and Thursdays, just Mondays.  YTBD.  Enjoy!

Love,
Allison Ellsworth, LAMFT